Neri Oxman Plagiarism Scandal
Billionaire investor Bill Ackman finds himself navigating another storm of controversy, this time involving his wife, Neri Oxman, and allegations of plagiarism in her MIT dissertation. This unfolding situation echoes Ackman's past criticisms of Harvard's president Claudine Gay and her handling of antisemitism on campus, creating a parallel narrative of academic scrutiny.
Oxman, an American-Israeli designer and esteemed MIT professor, is now at the center of a plagiarism controversy surrounding her 2010 doctoral dissertation. A recent Business Insider article has brought these accusations to light, though it's crucial to note that NBC News has yet to independently verify these claims.
The echoes of this academic scandal resonate with the criticisms previously leveled at Gay, particularly issues related to missing quotation marks and proper citations in key passages of Oxman's work.
In the midst of the controversy, Ackman, a vocal critic of Gay, took to X to defend his wife, emphasizing the human aspect of making mistakes. Ackman empathetically expressed, "Recognizing her humanity comes from acknowledging that she, like everyone, is prone to making mistakes."
Oxman's Response and Apology
Responding to the Business Insider report, Oxman issued a public apology on X, acknowledging and addressing the concerns raised. "I have always recognized the profound importance of the contributions of my peers and those who came before me," she stated.
The report specifically pointed out instances in four paragraphs of her extensive 330-page PhD dissertation, titled 'Material-based Design Computation.' The issues revolved around the omission of quotation marks for certain work, with Oxman assuring that proper references were provided at the end of each paragraph and in the detailed bibliography.
Oxman expressed regret for the errors, stating, "I have always recognized the profound importance of the contributions of my peers and those who came before me."
Challenges in Verification
Oxman shed light on the challenges she faced in thoroughly checking the claims made in the report. Some original sources were not available online, hindering her ability to confirm the accuracy of the citations. Oxman intends to verify the citations once she gains access to the original sources and has requested MIT to make any necessary corrections.
Having devoted 15 years to MIT, enrolling in the Ph.D. program in 2005, obtaining her doctorate in 2010, and joining the faculty that same year, Oxman departed from the institution in 2020 after marriage and relocation to New York City.
Ackman's History of Scrutiny
Bill Ackman's outspoken criticism extends beyond his wife's current situation. He has been a prominent critic of Harvard University and its handling of various issues, including campus protests related to the Israel-Hamas war and accusations of antisemitism. Despite the controversy surrounding Gay, Harvard's investigation revealed inadequate citation but found no violation of research misconduct standards. Gay eventually stepped down from her position.
On X, Ackman criticized the board's support for Gay, calling it a "grave and continuing reputational disaster." He called for the resignations of board members supporting Gay and disagreed with Harvard's decision to retain her as faculty.
In light of the accusations against Oxman, Ackman continued to show his support, emphasizing her acknowledgment of mistakes and commitment to rectifying them. He expressed on X, "You know that you struck a chord when they go after your wife, in this case, my love and partner in life."
Related Tags:-
O my god
ReplyDelete